Replies to This Discussion

Permalink Reply by Charles Humphries on December 10, 2018 at 13:46

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Tim Godsmark on December 10, 2018 at 15:04

Hi Everyone,

I emailed all the members of the COLPAI liaison group together with our councillors on behalf of GLERA on Sunday morning. My email is below:

Dear Steven,
As you may be aware Basterfield House, Bayer House, the Community Centre and the swimming pool all had to be evacuated early on Saturday morning because of a gas leak. It would appear that this may have been caused by something that was dropped on site on Friday with an impact that was described by residents of Basterfield as resembling an earth tremor and which may have dislodged the joint of a gas pipe.

Clearly this is a serious incident which, quite apart from the risk of an explosion, lead to several residents vomiting because of the fumes and many having to leave their homes in their nightwear on a cold and wet morning and stay away for over four hours

Presumably the incident on site has been reported to the HSE and no doubt that we will be informed if they start an investigation and I would be grateful if you could confirm that this has happened. 

I would also ask that you immediately organise a public meeting so that residents can get an understanding of the cause of the incident on site and how this may have led to the gas leak, what measures will be put into place to stop it happening again and what mitigation measures will be undertaken when works that cause vibration are taking place. Could I also ask that this meeting is attended by a contractor representative, the site manager, ISG’s health and safety advisor, a client representative and their Principal Designer.

 

It would also be useful for representatives of the housing department to attend to explain why no one from their department was present to give advice to residents.

Because of the seriousness of the situation I would be grateful for an immediate reply and the meeting to take place this week.

Yours,

Tim Godsmark
Chair Golden Lane Estate Residents’ Association
07815 437 028

I received a rather unsatisfactory answer saying that affected residents would be written to soon and that they would not organise a meeting to answer peoples questions. The question about whether the Health and Safety Executive had been notified was not answered. I replied with the following email:

Dear,

Thank you for replying but but that is not an acceptable response. If there had been a explosion the City would have been looking at millions of pounds of possible damages and quite possibly loss of life and another Ronan Point. 

I have personally taken in Residents yesterday, several had to seek accommodation in the pub and it was not well into the morning that a respite space was established in the Golden Lane Campus. Clearly there was no planning for an incident and there were no preparations by the City in place.

Writing to affected residents is all very well but there needs to be a public forum where their questions can be answered. The City also needs to devise and publish a plan for incidents of this sort.

You do not answer my question whether the HSE had been notified of the incident on Friday. I would be grateful for a response on this point.

Lastly this raises the whole question of whether is is appropriate to have gas supplies in multi-storey blocks of flats and whether the City should have replaced the heating systems with a communal system rather than new individual boilers. 

Yours,

Tim Godsmark

I have received no answer to this email. I have had a supportive email from Alderman David Graves in reply to my first email and it was good to know that he was present on Saturday morning.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Charles Humphries on December 10, 2018 at 15:40

The gas engineer who was called out to repair the leak apparently thought that the pipe was damaged through vandalism. There doesn't appear to be any substantiation for this. There is no sign of any forced locks in the undercroft or other damage, other than the regular lack of maintenance. In the years I have lived here there has never been an issue of "vandalism" in the undercroft, and it beggars belief that anyone would have chosen to try and damage a gas pipe, rather than break into a storage locker and that it should happen at the exact time that demolition works were going on in line with the gas pipe and a few metres away from Basterfield House.  

Nevertheless the demolition contractors were on site this morning and trying to justify their actions and dampen any speculation. When I queried it and showed them the video of the diggers they even asked me how I knew there was a pipe there at all - I had to point out I am only going by the yellow line on the ground with the word "GAS?" on it. I think a precautionary working hypothesis is that the pipe was damaged by the demolition works, and we should proceed on that basis until the cause is confirmed.

• ▶ Reply

Permalink Reply by Tim Godsmark on December 10, 2018 at 15:51

Hi have just received an email from the Director of Communities and Children's Services say the the Health and Safety Executive have been notified.

• ▶ Reply